Website redesign: when you need one, what it costs, and how to keep your rankings
A redesign can bring in more enquiries, or quietly wipe out the Google rankings you already have. Here’s how to tell if you need one, what affects the cost, and how to switch without losing traffic.
- Redesign when the site stops doing its job: few enquiries, hard to use on a phone, slow, or impossible to update.
- A redesign usually costs about the same as a new site of the same size, because most of the work is the same.
- The biggest risk is changing page addresses without redirects. Map every old URL to a new one before you launch.
- Google says to expect some ranking movement after a big change, and that it can take a few weeks to settle.
A new website can bring in more enquiries. It can also quietly wipe out the Google rankings your old one built up over years, if it’s switched over carelessly. Most of the difference comes down to a few hours of planning before launch.
This guide covers how to tell whether you need a redesign, what affects the cost, and the steps Google recommends so you keep your traffic.
Signs you need a redesign
| Sign | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Few calls or enquiries from the site | The site isn’t doing its main job |
| Awkward to use on a phone | Most local customers will see it on a phone first |
| Slow to load | Visitors leave before they see what you do |
| It doesn’t say what you do and where in the first screen | Visitors and Google can’t tell if you’re the right fit |
| One page lists every service | It can’t rank for each service separately |
| You can’t update it, or only the original builder can | Prices, services and photos go out of date |
| It looks dated next to competitors | Customers judge trust by looks in seconds |
If only the last row applies, a lighter refresh may be enough. If several apply, a redesign usually pays for itself.
Redesign or refresh?
| Refresh | Redesign |
|---|---|
| Same structure and pages | New structure, often new pages |
| New photos, colours, clearer text, faster loading | New design, rewritten content, new features such as booking |
| Low risk to rankings | Needs a redirect plan to protect rankings |
What a redesign costs
A redesign usually costs about the same as building a new site of the same size, because most of the work is the same: planning, writing, design and build. It can cost less if your existing text and photos are good and the structure stays similar, and more if you’re adding features such as booking or a shop.
For UK prices, see how much a website costs in the UK. If you’re weighing up doing it yourself on a builder, see Wix vs a web designer.
How to redesign without losing your Google rankings
Google’s guidance on moving pages comes down to a few steps. These are the ones that matter for a small business site:
- List what you have. Export every page address from your sitemap or Search Console, and note which pages get traffic and enquiries.
- Keep what works. Pages that rank well should keep their topic and most of their content, even if the design changes.
- Map every old address to a new one. Google recommends preparing a mapping from current URLs to new URLs. Keep the same address wherever you can.
- Use permanent redirects. Where an address changes, set up a 301 (permanent) redirect from the old address to the closest new page, not to the homepage.
- Update internal links so your pages link to the new addresses directly.
- Submit your new sitemap in Google Search Console after launch.
- Watch Search Console for errors and dropped pages over the following weeks, and fix anything that’s missing.
Google says to expect some ranking movement after a significant change, and that it can take a few weeks or more for Google to show the new addresses instead of the old ones. If your business is seasonal, launch in a quieter period.
A simple redesign process
- Review: what the current site gets right, what it gets wrong, and which pages bring enquiries.
- Plan: the new page list, one page per service, and the redirect map.
- Content: rewrite or improve the text before design starts.
- Design and build: mobile first, with clear contact buttons on every page.
- Launch and check: redirects tested, sitemap submitted, forms tested, Search Console watched.
That’s how we handle redesigns as part of our web design in Birmingham: the redirect plan is part of the project, not an afterthought.
Sources
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my website needs a redesign?
Look at what it’s achieving. If it brings in few enquiries, is awkward on a phone, loads slowly, doesn’t say clearly what you do and where, or you can’t update it yourself, a redesign is likely worth it. If it works but looks dated, small improvements may be enough.
Will a redesign hurt my Google rankings?
It can, mainly if page addresses change without redirects or if content that ranked well is removed. Map every old address to its new one, use permanent (301) redirects, keep your best-performing content, and watch Google Search Console after launch. Google says some ranking movement during a big change is normal.
How long does a website redesign take?
For a small business site, usually two to six weeks, depending on the number of pages and how much new content is needed. Planning redirects and checking Search Console afterwards adds a little time but protects your traffic.
How often should you redesign a website?
There’s no fixed schedule. Redesign when the site stops doing its job: few enquiries, hard to use on a phone, slow, or impossible to update. Between redesigns, keep improving the pages that matter most, such as service pages and contact routes, which is cheaper and safer for your rankings.
Can I use AI to redesign my website?
AI tools can help with parts of it, such as drafting text, suggesting layouts or creating images. You still need accurate content about your business, a plan for page addresses and redirects, and checks on real phones before launch. Treat what AI produces as a first draft, not a finished site.